The complex effects of retirement on health

Retirement offers the potential for improved health, yet also creates the risk of triggering bad health behavior

Swiss Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training, Switzerland, and IZA, Germany

one-pager full article

Elevator pitch

Retirement offers the opportunity to give up potentially risky, unhealthy, and/or stressful work, which is expected to foster improvements in retirees’ health. However, retirement also bears the risk that retirees suffer from the loss of daily routines, physical and/or mental activity, a sense of identity and purpose, and social interactions, which may lead them to adopt unhealthy behaviors. Depending on the relative importance of the different mechanisms, retirement may either improve or cause a deterioration of retirees’ health, or eventually have no effect on it at all.

Retirement’s effects on mortality

Key findings

Pros

Retirement is one of the most fundamental and potentially most disruptive events in an individual’s life.

Methodological innovations and access to large administrative data sets have advanced the credibility of empirical estimates.

Retirement may either be beneficial (e.g. if it is voluntary) or detrimental (e.g. if it cuts all social contacts) to retirees’ health.

The effects of retirement on health work primarily through changes in retirees’ health-related behavior.

Cons

Reverse causality makes it very difficult to establish causality.

The outcome measured and time horizon under consideration are important methodological issues.

The most credible empirical evidence available remains ambiguous.

Due to its ambiguity, it is not possible to derive uniform policy implications from the available evidence.

Individuals react differently to becoming a retiree, depending on both personal and contextual factors.

Author's main message

Knowing the health effects of retirement is important for an optimal design of pension policies. Empirical research suggests that retirement may either improve retirees’ health, reduce it, or eventually have no effects at all. This variation may best be rationalized by the existence of heterogeneous effects across groups of individuals who respond differently to becoming a retiree. This point of view not only acknowledges the startling complexity of adjustments eventually triggered by retirement, it also offers the opportunity to focus on those factors or contexts that lead to either positive or negative health effects of retirement. Importantly, it also implies that there are no uniform policy recommendations.

Full citation

Full citation

Data source(s)

Data type(s)

Method(s)

Countries