Public attitudes toward immigration—Determinants and unknowns

Sociopsychological factors are much more important than economic issues in shaping attitudes toward immigration

University of British Columbia (Okanagan Campus), Canada

one-pager full article

Elevator pitch

Public attitudes toward immigration play an important role in influencing immigration policy and immigrants’ integration experience. This highlights the importance of a systematic examination of these public attitudes and their underlying drivers. Evidence increasingly suggests that while a majority of individuals favor restrictive immigration policies, particularly against ethnically different immigrants, there exists significant variation in these public views by country, education, age, and so on. In addition, sociopsychological factors play a significantly more important role than economic concerns in driving these public attitudes and differences.

Do you think the number of immigrants to
                        your country nowadays should be...

Key findings

Pros

Recent surveys suggest that the majority of people support relatively restrictive immigration policies and would like to see a decrease in the number of immigrants.

Personal characteristics of survey respondents and immigrant groups significantly influence attitudes toward immigration and immigrants.

Sociopsychological factors, such as issues related to ethnic/cultural identity, play a substantially more important role than economic concerns in driving anti-immigration attitudes.

Cons

Designing surveys that allow for cross-country comparisons for countries with different immigration experiences and legal structures is challenging.

Researchers’ current understanding of the inter-play between micro-, meso-, and macro-level factors remains limited.

To identify and disentangle the various causal channels that shape public attitudes toward immigration more research is needed.

The role of macro-level institutional and sociopolitical forces in shaping public attitudes has been largely ignored.

Author's main message

The primacy of sociopsychological factors in shaping attitudes toward immigration highlights the limited effectiveness of economic policy interventions in reducing anti-immigration sentiments. A comprehensive and effective approach to address negative attitudes toward immigration therefore necessitates careful attention and engagement of sociopsychological concerns, prejudices, and stereotypes that underlie such opposition. Policymakers should avoid restricting public views toward immigration to considerations around individual behavior driven by material self-interest when evidence clearly suggests that they do not belong to that framework.

Full citation

Full citation

Data source(s)

Data type(s)

Method(s)

Countries

How can we improve IZA World of Labor? Click here to take our 5-minute survey and enter a prize draw.