Leveraging covariates in regression discontinuity designs

Proper use of covariates in regression discontinuity designs can enhance empirical scientific discoveries and evidence-based policy decisions

Princeton University, US, and Amazon Inc., US

Princeton University, US

one-pager full article

Elevator pitch

It is common practice to incorporate additional covariates in empirical economics. In the context of regression discontinuity (RD) designs, covariate adjustment plays multiple roles, making it essential to understand its impact on analysis and conclusions. Typically implemented via local least squares regressions, covariate adjustment can serve three main distinct purposes: (i) improving the efficiency of RD average causal effect estimators, (ii) learning about heterogeneous RD policy effects, and (iii) changing the RD parameter of interest.

illustration

Key findings

Pros

Precision of RD causal effect estimators can be improved by correctly using pre-intervention covariates.

When properly implemented, covariate adjustment can uncover interesting heterogeneous RD causal effects.

Various other RD policy effects of interest can be learned by correctly incorporating co-variates in the analysis.

Cons

Understanding empirical results based on covariate-adjusted RD estimates requires careful consideration.

Covariate adjustment cannot restore the validity of an RD design without strong parametric assumptions.

Empirical work leveraging covariates in RD designs is often undisciplined and ad hoc, potentially leading to invalid empirical findings and policy prescriptions.

Author's main message

When applied correctly, covariate adjustment in RD designs can significantly enhance empirical analysis and strengthen policy conclusions. However, the use of covariates across RD studies is often inconsistent and ad hoc, undermining both the credibility and replicability of findings. Adopting best methodological practices for covariate adjustment in RD designs can improve efficiency and support rigorous heterogeneity analysis. Additionally, pre-intervention covariates can be leveraged to modify the RD parameter of interest, though this requires imposing additional, sometimes stringent, modeling assumptions.

Full citation

Full citation

Data source(s)

Data type(s)

Method(s)

Countries