Health effects of job insecurity Updated

Job insecurity adversely affects health, but employability policies and otherwise better job quality can mitigate the effects

UCL Institute of Education, UK

one-pager full article

Elevator pitch

The fear of unemployment has increased around the world in the wake of Covid-19. Research has shown that job insecurity affects both mental and physical health, though the effects are lower when employees are easily re-employable. The detrimental effects of job insecurity could be partly mitigated if employers improved other aspects of job quality that support better health. But as job insecurity is felt by many more people than just the unemployed, the negative health effects during recessions are multiplied and extend through the majority of the population. This reinforces the need for effective, stabilising macroeconomic policies, most especially at this time of pandemic.

Effect of insecurity and unemployment
                        on women’s mental health in Australia

Key findings

Pros

Many cross-sectional studies in epidemiology, psychology, and economics show a strong connection between job insecurity and poor physical or mental health.

Some studies confirm that the effects of job insecurity on health are causal, particularly in relation to mental health, headaches, eyestrains, and skin problems.

The size of the effect of job insecurity on health can be as large as the effect of unemployment.

Cons

Many cross-sectional and longitudinal studies do not prove causation, and there are a few countries in which no association is found.

Longitudinal studies confirm that the harmful effects of job insecurity on health are mitigated when employees are re-employable.

Social support is associated with higher well-being, and may help in situations of high insecurity; more organizational participation, higher pay, lower work intensity, safer working conditions and greater autonomy can all mitigate the detrimental health effects of job insecurity.

Little is known about how people may or may not adapt to job insecurity over time or how they may compensate for the associated uncertainty.

Author's main message

Job insecurity has become an increasing problem since the great recession and as labor markets have become more flexible. It is well established that job insecurity, like unemployment, has causal detrimental effects on mental and physical health. Workers’ health is not just a matter for employees and employers, but also for public policy. Governments should count the health cost of restrictive policies that generate unemployment and insecurity, while promoting employability through skills training. Health policy should also encourage social support, employee participation, and improved working conditions.

Full citation

Full citation

Data source(s)

Data type(s)

Method(s)

Countries